文章 Articles

Chinese herb farmers unaware of pesticide health risks

After reports of pesticide residue in traditional Chinese herbs, Greenpeace has profiled three farmers, highlighting the low-level of awareness of health risks

Article image

Greenpeace is currently investigating pesticide residue in Chinese herbal medicine and the use of toxic chemicals by farmers (Image by: Simon Lim/Greenpeace)

The excessive use of chemical fertilisers and pesticides in China is a major problem. Figures from the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences’ (CAAS) Soil and Fertiliser Institute have shown that in half of Chinese provinces, average levels of nitrogen fertiliser use exceed the internationally accepted limit of 225kg per hectare.

As well as degrading soil quality, overuse of pesticides has also been linked to food safety problems, as shown by the high levels of pesticide residue recently found in traditional Chinese herbs.

Chinese agriculture appears to have become worryingly over-reliant on using pesticides. “Farmers use these chemicals as they feel like it,” Xu Ming, from the Ministry of Agriculture, told chinadialogue last year. “The Ministry of Agriculture has standards for use, but if the standard says to use one bottle cap’s worth of pesticide the farmers will use three, just to make sure.”

Although there are agricultural technology offices in China’s villages, Xu Ming has said there is no way to monitor what individual farmers are doing. As the following three case studies of herb-growing farmers show, investigated as part of Greenpeace’s Heal the Herbs’ campaign, the problems are deep-seated and illustrate the need for better education, not only about the harmful consequences of pesticides, but also the possibilities of using more environmentally-friendly alternatives.

Auntie Ye: a honeysuckle farmer, Pingyi County, Shandong

Like many of the honeysuckle growers in the area, Auntie Ye is illiterate. When asked how to manage powdery mildew, she takes a bottle of carbendazim from her basket. She selects her pesticide based on its shape and colour, rather than the dense lines of description on the bottle’s label.


Auntie Ye, a honeysuckle farmer from Pingyi County, Shandong

Auntie Ye says she is always careful to pay attention to any recommendations from the pesticide sellers, but she has never been told which pesticides are highly toxic, and that she must avoid skin contact with them. Wearing gloves and masks seems, to her, an unnecessary precaution. As far as she knows, pesticides have not been banned by national legislation so they must be safe. Yet in her hand she holds a bottle of omethoate, a pesticide that has been banned.

Auntie Ye sees no reason to separate her vegetable garden from her honeysuckle fields, and applies the same pesticides to both.  She mistakenly believes that washing the vegetables is enough to remove any pesticide residue.

The only creatures she protects from the pesticides are her chickens. She senses they are more sensitive to the chemical's deadly effects, so she places fencing around the chicken shed and tries to avoid letting them have direct contact. As for her eight year old grandson, she lets him play in the fields where pesticides are sprayed.

Xiaogui: a sanqi farmer, Wensham City, Yunnan

Xiaogui has seven or eight years’ experience growing the herb sanqi. Like many people in his village, he and his sister's sole income is dependent on farming. The entire Wenshan area specialises in growing Sanqi, with every household planting at least a few acres of the herb.

Sanqi is a very labour-intensive herb to cultivate. Firstly it should be grown on "virgin land", which means at least two or three fallow years before it can be planted. Secondly, it must be planted alongside other plants supported by poles, in order to create shade. All of this means extensive manual labour.


Xiaogui, a sanqi farmer from Wensham City, Yunnan

In Yunnan, women usually pick the herbs, while men sow the seeds in January. Sanqi is extremely  vulnerable to pests and disease, so farmers have become accustomed to applying a mixture of pesticides.

Xiaogui says that during planting he uses particularly potent pesticides such as carbofuran and phorate. As it is used to kill insects that live underground, it is usually sprinkled directly onto the soil. This is combined with a variety of other pesticides applied once a week or, during the rainy season, twice a week. Xiaogui says he has never really been taught how best to use these pesticides – he has just worked it out himself.

Xiaogui is not familiar with the harm these pesticides can cause to his health. This means that when he and his sister's husband are handling these toxic chemicals, they wear little protection. Xiaogui's brother-in-law reports feelings of dizziness when mixing the chemicals in the pesticide tank, but no one in the village bothers to wear a mask or gloves, so neither do they.

Xiaogui's daughter is currently in fourth grade, and on the weekends will help out on the fields by weeding or catching mice. Xiaogui's four-year-old son also likes to play in the field. His family isn't careful about keeping the pesticides away from the children and, after spraying, they only use a simple detergent to wash their hands and clothes.

Xiaogui acquired his pesticides from Chinese herbal medicine traders, who did not once ask about his methods of application. The farmer says he has no idea where his herbs are sold.

Uncle Li: a honeysuckle farmer, Pingyi County, Shandong

Whenever beekeepers run into Uncle Li, they tend to bring up pesticides and ask when he's planning to spray. That's because Uncle Li's honeysuckle field is located right next to a bee farm, and bees are highly sensitive to pesticides. As the bees are most active in the day, Uncle Lee only applies pesticides to his crops after six o'clock and tries to do so away from the beehives.


Uncle Li, a honeysuckle farmer from Pingyi County, Shandong

Uncle Li has been planting honeysuckle for as long as he can remember - it's a practice that extends back generations in his family. It is a perennial plant, and every year he applies pesticides at least twice: once at the end of March when the plants are beginning to sprout, and again in May when the flowers bloom. He commonly uses the pesticides omethoate and carbendazim, and the amounts grow more concentrated when the flowers bloom. This is also when the bees will be more active around the plants, and thus risk being more exposed to the toxins. Less than one week after the flowers bloom, he picks the honeysuckle.

Uncle Li is convinced that rainwater will simply wash away any residues, or that after two or three days the residue will disappear on its own accord. When we showed him a mask and a pair of gloves, he reacted with ambivalence, telling us that farmers are already accustomed to working with pesticides without special protection. Doing so would simply feel cumbersome.

When discussing the honeysuckle of his hometown, a look of pride appears on Uncle Li's face. He tells us production in the region is most authentic, and that the country's largest pharmacies all source their honeysuckle from the area.

Big traditional Chinese medicine companies like Tong Ren Tang do not directly buy from Uncle Li. They acquire his honeysuckle through middlemen, which means Uncle Li can never be sure exactly where his goods end up. These middlemen have no interest in pesticide usage; they only look at the honeysuckle colour and quality when deciding whether to buy.

These case studies are edited versions of profiles featured in the Greenpeace 'Heal the Herbs’ campaign

Now more than ever…

chinadialogue is at the heart of the battle for truth on climate change and its challenges at this critical time.

Our readers are valued by us and now, for the first time, we are asking for your support to help maintain the rigorous, honest reporting and analysis on climate change that you value in a 'post-truth' era.

Support chinadialogue

发表评论 Post a comment

评论通过管理员审核后翻译成中文或英文。 最大字符 1200。

Comments are translated into either Chinese or English after being moderated. Maximum characters 1200.

评论 comments

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

追究农民有什么用

没有农产品食品安全监测,当然农民想怎么干就怎么干。即使他知道毒性很大也不会罢手。要不然怎么会有那么多不法商贩呢。

What's the point in investigating farmers?

Since there are are no safety systems in place to monitor agricultural food products, farmers will inevitably do whatever they feel like. Even if they are aware of the huge amounts of poison, they will not simply give up selling it, otherwise how could there be so many illegal traders?