文章 Articles

The slaughter of migratory birds in Hunan

Yan Jiawen and Li Feng undercover the shocking killing of migrating birds in Hunan province, south China

Article image

Traders say the cost is determined by how protected the bird is – the higher the level of protection, the more expensive (Image by Li Feng)

The article won the prize for Biggest Impact at chinadialogue’s China Environmental Press Awards, and lead directly to a huge nationwide “let the birds fly” campaign.

Their report revealed the shocking slaughter of migratory birds and led to three key counties signing an agreement on joint protection of the birds and the formation of a joint force to patrol the borders between them. Hunan Forestry Police cracked down on hunting in seven cities and prefectures, while the State Forestry Administration dispatched a working group to coordinate the fight against bird hunting.


The Luoxiao mountains in Hunan province rise to over 2,000 meters at their peak. From autumn the strong mountain winds make a thick jacket essential. But the mountain air is clear and on a good night the sky is full of stars. Autumn also brings the spectacle of huge flocks of migrating birds heading south through the mountain passes.

But what should be a path to warmth and food becomes death for countless birds. The passes of China’s second most important route for migratory birds are now slaughtering grounds, filled with illegal hunters and their guns and nets.

Bird-hunting is popular in Guidong and Yanling counties, and everyone knows it goes on. In the past hunters would burn wood or tyres to light up the mountain side in order to attract the birds. Today they use powerful LED lights for better range. Rain and fog are the best weather for the hunters.

In September, 2012, on our first trip as “hunters” into the mountains we found around a hundred of them sitting in holes dug for shelter. With no guns or other equipment, we would have aroused suspicion, so we stayed a safe distance away.  In October, we took infrared cameras so we could get closer. This time we masqueraded as buyers, carrying large bags through the hills.

The hunters work in groups, with a clear division of labour: light-operators, shooters, and collectors. There are also outsiders in expensive cars who come to shoot the birds for fun.. One hunter said that on October 3rd, 2012, a single group of hunters had collected over one tonne of bird carcasses.

Early on the 10th of October we visited the Guidong market as buyers. More than ten traders quickly surrounded us hawking their wild birds. One trader said that people sell birds almost every day, at up to several hundred yuan per bird. The sellers also said they could arrange for swans to be supplied at request. Alongside the live birds, dried meat was also for sale. Most local restaurants sell bird dishes, ranging in price from tens of yuan to the hundreds. Cost is determined by how protected the bird is – the higher the level of protection, the more expensive.

We immediately reported this to the Guidong Forestry Bureau, who visited the market the same day – somehow the traders who’d been present a few minutes previously had suddenly disappeared. The authorities were able to confiscate three birds left behind.

For the birds, surviving being shot is just the start of an even worse fate. Their beaks are bound, their feathers plucked one by one. There’s a local belief that blood taken from a live bird is highly nourishing. The only time the locals stopped eating birds was during the bird flu scare.

“The slaughter would stop if there was no business to be done. Such hunting will eventually lead to an imbalanced ecology,” said one ornithologist.

Deng Xuejian, a professor at Hunan Normal University, investigated the problem and came up with a bold solution: designate the area an international bird-watching reserve. He thinks the locals could then make money from tourism, spurring the local economy and improving living conditions. “When people realise the birds attract tourists and provide a living, do you think they’ll still hunt them?”

Now more than ever…

chinadialogue is at the heart of the battle for truth on climate change and its challenges at this critical time.

Our readers are valued by us and now, for the first time, we are asking for your support to help maintain the rigorous, honest reporting and analysis on climate change that you value in a 'post-truth' era.

Support chinadialogue

发表评论 Post a comment

评论通过管理员审核后翻译成中文或英文。 最大字符 1200。

Comments are translated into either Chinese or English after being moderated. Maximum characters 1200.

评论 comments

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

邪恶

人类从根本上来说都是邪恶的!

evil

Humans are basically evil!

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

哀鸿道

全力支持邓学建教授的建议,将千年鸟道打造成一个国际级观鸟景区,那真是太好了。如果成事,我一定跟朋友们一起去桂东观鸟。

Lament over the death of migratory birds

I completely support Professor Deng Xuejian's proposal that the government should designate the area as an international bird-watching reserve. It's brilliant! If Guidong becomes a scenic spot, I will definitely go there with my friends to see the birds.

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

既粗暴又野蛮

我赞成建观鸟景区的办法。这是很容易的事。但是,即使不这样做,中国政府也必须查处猎杀珍稀物种的行为,必须彻底而严厉地执行。
我希望这个调查可以提供鸟类品种和它们大致数目等更多细节。并且,也应该有定期的跟踪以确保问题得到解决。

OUTRAGEOUS & BARBARIC

I agree with the birding tourism solution. It's a no-brainer. But, even without that, the Chinese government must crack down on all hunting of protected species. Enforcement must be comprehensive and severe.

I wish the story would have provided more details on the identities of the bird species involved and their relative numbers. Also, there should be periodic follow-ups done to see if this problem is being fixed.