文章 Articles

China’s great disappearing lake

Northern China’s largest body of freshwater is shrinking, but can it be saved? Huo Weiya travelled to Inner Mongolia to find out.

Article image

Dalai Lake is shrinking. For years, the water level of northern China’s largest freshwater lake – lying on the Hulunbuir grasslands of Inner Mongolia, close to the borders with Mongolia and Russia – has been falling. Since 2009, the local government has been trying to halt the decline by siphoning off water from the Argun River, which forms part of the boundary between Russia and China. But Dalai’s long-term future is still unclear.

Dalai is a huge body of water – the fifth biggest of China’s freshwater lakes. And its importance in maintaining the ecological balance of the Hulunbuir grasslands, currently the healthiest in China, has earned it the nickname “Kidney of the Grasslands”. In 1986, Inner Mongolia established the Dalai Lake Nature Reserve in order to protect the site’s rare birds, wetlands and grasslands ecology. In 1992, the area was upgraded to a national nature reserve and, in 2001, it was included on a list of internationally important wetlands.

But recognition has not prevented decline. “The water level drops every day. It hasn’t come back up for seven or eight years,” the 60-year-old owner of Golden Sands Holiday Village, a resort on the north-east bank of the lake, told me when I travelled to Hulunbuir in September last year. The grasslands were already yellowing and the herders were driving to and from their homes with loads of grass, harvested for winter fodder.

The owner of Golden Sands (who asked not to be identified by name) and his wife are not herders. They started their resort business 10 years ago. July and August is their busy period, when they offer tourists grassland experiences like swimming in the lake and fishing with rod or nets.

When I met the owner, it was clear weather, and he pointed out the white sands by the edge of the lake, explaining that the wind blows for four days out of every five. “As soon as the wind gets up, the air is filled with sand,” he said. He believes desertification of the grasslands is a direct result of the lake’s shrinking size.

Falling water levels have left a 600-metre wide stretch of white sand between the grasslands and the lake. According to media reports, satellite surveys calculated the area of the lake to be 2,370 square kilometres in April 2000. By June, 2010, it had shrunk to 1,850 square kilometres – a loss of 520 square kilometres.

Manzhouli, a border city north-west of the lake, once planned to use water from here to create its own manmade lake, with a “Lovers’ Island”, but it was forced to abandon the idea due to the falling water levels at Dalai.

The owner of Golden Sands blames the lake’s decline on years of unusually dry weather: “It doesn’t snow all summer, and then we get big snows in the spring – like this year. It gets so cold that even us locals can’t take it.”

Liu Songtao is deputy director of the Dalai Lake National Nature Reserve management bureau. He agreed that the shifting ecology of the grasslands and the lake is strongly affected by the climate, and that the dwindling size of the lake is due to sustained dry weather. 

The lake gets its water from the Kherlen and Wuerxun rivers, as well as from rain falling onto the lake and its surroundings. Liu said that temperatures on the grasslands have been rising for over 10 years, with annual average temperatures increasing by about three degrees Celsius between 1960 and 2009, while precipitation has fallen. The amount of water flowing in from the two rivers has also been decreasing. In 2007, none came through at all.

The falling water level has exacerbated the degradation of the grasslands. “There is a direct link between the worsening lake ecology and the degradation and desertification of the grasslands,” Yang Yusheng, a water engineer with Hulunbuir city, told the media last year. Yang said that falling water levels are causing groundwater from the surrounding area to flow inwards, lowering the level of groundwater under the grasslands and worsening desertification. “Dalai Lake is the kidney of the Hulunbuir grasslands – and of course you’re going to suffer if your kidney stops working.”

The effects of falling water levels are not only felt in China, but also in Mongolia and Russia. In 1994, the three nations established the Dauria International Protected Area, of which the Dalai National Nature Reserve is a member. In 2005, Mongolia formed plans to retain a tenth of the flow of the Kherlun River for development of its local mining industry. But, explained Liu, the project was abandoned after discussion between the three parties.

To halt Dalai’s decline, the city of Hulunbuir came up with a plan: it would take 1.05 billion cubic metres of water a year from the 3.7 billion that flow through the Hailar River (the upstream name of the Argun) to replenish the lake. China’s State Environmental Protection Agency (now the Ministry of Environmental Protection) approved the plan in April 2006 and, in the spring of 2007, work began.

But the scheme met with opposition from Russia. The governor of the Trans-Baikal territory wrote a letter to Russia’s ministers of natural resources and foreign affairs, saying: “If this project is completed, 1,500 square kilometres of river banks along the Erguna will be irreparably damaged.”

Eugene Simonov, coordinator at the Rivers without Boundaries Coalition – an NGO formed in July 2009 by Russian, Mongolian and US experts on the Heilongjiang River basin – also opposed the scheme. He said that, if completed, the project would have a major impact on the wetlands and communities of the lower reaches of the Hailar River and set a dangerous precedent for water-engineering projects and unsustainable use of water.  

An official from the Hulunbuir Environmental Protection Bureau, who asked not to be named, said that a diplomatic note from Russia triggered visits from officials from the State Environmental Protection Agency, the Ministry of Water Resources and the State Forestry Administration, and that the project was temporarily put on hold. “But in the end it went ahead, so the governments must have come to an agreement,” the official said.

According to the water authorities in Hulunbuir, the project to bring river water to the lake was completed last August and a dedicated office has been set up to manage the process. In light of Russian opposition, they lowered the amount of water they intend to draw from the river to 390 million cubic metres per year. One of the officials in charge of the project said that this figure was not set in stone, however – they will control the flow with a sluice gate and take more water when the river is high.

Liu said that the gate would only be opened for short periods, and usually only during flood season. They would not open it when the river is low, he said, because of downstream considerations: “Even if we didn’t care what Russia thought, we need to consider the Chinese people downstream – they need water for drinking, for livestock, for their daily lives.”

But the project employee posted at the sluice gate said that it had never been closed, and that water from the Hailar River was being constantly channelled towards the lake. The gate would only be lowered if there was too much water, he said.

From the Mongol yurts at the Golden Sands Holiday Village, it was possible to see Hulungou, where the water from the Hailar reaches Dalai Lake. The resort owner said that he was pleased about the extra water, but that it wouldn’t be enough to save the lake. “The copper mine on the other side of the lake is taking out as much as the new channel brings in,” he said.

The “copper mine” in question is Gujinyu Mining’s copper and molybdenum pit, a China Gold Group subsidiary. In 2008, it emerged that the mining company had laid a pipe to draw water from the lake, and the holiday village boss believes they are still using the lake’s resources.

However, Liu said that the changing shape of the lake is not being caused by local human activity and that natural changes and global climate change are to blame. “There’s no industry around the lake, just livestock farming,” he said. And, in his opinion, there is little the nature reserve can do about the shrinking lake. “All we can do is to keep the reserve intact, try to prevent further deterioration and ensure that, when the conditions are right, Dalai will be able to recover.”

Huo Weiya is a freelance journalist based in Beijing.

Homepage image from suiyanlu

Now more than ever…

chinadialogue is at the heart of the battle for truth on climate change and its challenges at this critical time.

Our readers are valued by us and now, for the first time, we are asking for your support to help maintain the rigorous, honest reporting and analysis on climate change that you value in a 'post-truth' era.

Support chinadialogue

发表评论 Post a comment

评论通过管理员审核后翻译成中文或英文。 最大字符 1200。

Comments are translated into either Chinese or English after being moderated. Maximum characters 1200.

评论 comments

Default thumb avatar



happening elsewhere?

Great article. I would be interested to know if the same thing is happening to other lakes. Huo Weiya, do you know if there are parallel examples happening elsewhere in the world that may provide helpful lessons for the management of Dalai?

Default thumb avatar


先亮明一下身份,也是对文章的小小纠错。笔者张亚东,绿色龙江的负责人,也是无国界河流网络(Rivers Without Boundaries)的中国协调人。这个网络致力于通过联合倡导行动保护欧亚大陆东北部跨国界流域健康和推动最佳的河流管理。20个组织和一些专家参与发起,不以国籍而论,无论是俄蒙美,还是中日韩德法英,欢迎加入。

Saving Dalai Lake- Chinese coordinator for Rivers without Boundaries

I am very pleased that issues in Erguna river basin has once again been brought to people's attention, especially as this article has been reposted on over ten websites.
Let me first introduce myself, and also correct a small error in the article. My name is Zhang Yadong, and I am in charge of Green Longjiang while also being the Chinese coordinator for Rivers without Boundaries. This network is dedicated to calling for action to protect the health of transborder river basins in Northeast Eurasia, while also pushing for best practice in river management. It was launched by twenty groups and several experts, and people of any nationality are welcome to join.
The article "China's great disappearing lake" is not long, but it combines the author's own research and the results of much research into one. Starting with the protection of Dalai Lake, it moves on to touch on aspects such as the Dauria International Protected Area, the project to use river water to replenish the lake, the Erguna river, and industrial development. However, all these can actually be combined into one large problem- the crisis facing the wetlands in the mid to lower reaches of the Erguna river, roughly the "over 1500 square kilometres of river bank" along the "middle reaches of the Erguna river" mentioned by Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.
These wetlands are a precious transborder ecosystem. 60-70% of the land is in China, where there are three protected areas- the Erguna Wetlands Protected Area, the Huliyetu Wetlands Protected Area, and the Erka Wetlands Protected Area. It is widely known that this is a bottleneck on the global bird migration route from east Asia to Australia- every year, around 20 million birds nest and breed here as they migrate. It is an important nesting ground for as many as 19 species of bird on the ICUN Red List, including internationally important numbers of swan geese, red-crowned cranes, white-naped cranes, red-necked stints, broad-billed sandpipers, bean geese, tundra swans, whooper swans, and gadwall.
Although it is one of China's most important wetlands, its importance is not well known, and even fewer people know about the crisis it is facing. Just as deputy director of the Dalai Lake National Nature Reserve management bureau Liu Songtao said, the shrinking surface area of Dalai Lake is caused by drought. This is also the problem that has been facing wetlands in the entire mid to low reaches of the Erguna for the last 12 years.
However, research has shown that this kind of drought is part of a natural cycle. Of the many natural factors that moulded these wetlands, the natural alternation in climate between wet and dry and flooding of the river are the two most important. The complex natural climate cycle has given the freshwater nesting grounds running through this area complex changes between wet and dry. In wet periods, there are many lakes and shallow ponds around the mid to lower reaches of the Erguna which are the ideal nesting ground for most species of wild animal. In dry periods, most of these areas are no longer so hospitable, but the floodplain of the river still maintains a steady flow of water, providing a stable, though not ideal, nesting area. Wetlands in the floodplain rely on floodwater for their existence, and floodwater is different to changes in the water level of the lake. In drought years, flooding will still happen often; the wet/dry cycle is a long one, but floodwater is more irregular. Specifically, the area of Dalai Lake has shrunk and regrown many times with the natural cycle of wet and dry, but flooding on differing scales happens in the mid to lower reaches of the Erguna nearly every year.
A healthy ecosystem is a fluid balance: life must adapt to these changes in order to survive, and the ancient Mongolian people are no exception. But now, much societal and economic behaviour not only not adapting to the environment, but going in completely the other direction. Water development and diversion projects dramatically destroy this fluid balance in a short space of time, with serious and irreversible effect; industries with a high demand for water, such as mining, petroleum, and coal power, do not consider adapting to the local environment and climate but rather let the chase for short term profit take precedence over the long term environmental costs.