文章 Articles

Tortilla turmoil

An increase in demand for corn as a biofuel ingredient has sent prices of Mexico’s staple food soaring -- and protesters on to the streets. Jo Tuckerman reports.
Article image

The fire under the open stove crackles as Catalina Mendez prepares dozens of the handmade corn tortillas she sells every day. Her tiny business has barely broken even, she says, since the recent US demand for ethanol biofuel made from corn – what we call maize -- began pushing up the price of the local corn.

“Not that I would stop now, even if I was making nothing,” the 69-year-old says, slipping in and out of Nahuatl, the language spoken by the Aztecs. “Making tortillas is in my blood.”

A symbol of national unity, corn is king in Mexico. But for how long?

The first shudders came at the beginning of the year, when president George W Bush told America he wanted to produce 35 billion gallons (over 130 billion litres) of renewable fuels by 2017. As the price of corn futures on the Chicago stock exchange went up sharply, so did the price of tortillas at the hole-in-the-wall shops in barrios across Mexico.

The shock of paying 50% more overnight for Mexico’s staple food sent thousands of people on to the capital’s streets. The government hesitated, but by February had negotiated a price freeze that is still in force today. An aura of vulnerability has hung over corn in Mexico ever since.

At a recent press conference, the upbeat minister of agriculture, Alberto Cárdenas , attempted to dispel the disquiet. Mexican agribusinesses had responded by growing one million more hectares of corn, and Cárdenas waved statistics indicating a 12% increase in the all-important summer harvest in the northern state of Sinaloa, where three quarters of national production is concentrated. “Supply is guaranteed,” the minister declared. “This country has more corn today and that will happen every year until the end of this government."

But questions remain. The additional one million hectares growing corn means one million fewer hectares available to produce other crops. Because fewer beans -- the second most important staple in the Mexican diet -- have been planted, their price has gone up, too. In addition, the price of meat, poultry and dairy products, which are fed on corn imported from the United States, is increasing.

The stickiest issue is perhaps the impact on Mexico's two million small-scale corn producers who are the backbone of what is left of its rural economy -- already in such decline that many keep afloat only with money sent home by relatives working in the US. Theoretically, the corn price rise should have been a welcome boost to farmers in these areas. In practice, it has not happened that way. "We didn't get paid any more for our corn this year," explains farmer Orlando Ramírez.

Dearth of infrastructure, lack of machinery, inadequate information, and weak motivation are just some of the reasons behind the uncompetitive Mexican small farmer. Ramírez says he expects to harvest two tonnes of corn from the hectare he planted this year -- less than a sixth of the yields expected by the agribusinesses in Sinaloa. The corn ethanol bandwagon is passing by farmers like him.

Worries over corn shortages in the US are not unfounded. The scale of the American ethanol rush is staggering. There are 121 ethanol biorefineries in the US, according to the Renewable Fuels Association (RFA), producing nearly 6.3 billion gallons a year. A further 76 refineries are under construction, which together with expansions in existing facilities should double that capacity. And that is still only just over a third of Bush's 2017 target.

Víctor Suárez, spokesman for Mexico-based ANEC, an activist group of corn farmers, imagines two opposed nightmare scenarios. In the first, he says, American corn farmers will not be able to keep up with the corn demand and the big Sinaloa producers will step in to the fill the void, leaving Mexicans without tortillas. In the second, the ethanol craze burns itself out, prompting US corn producers to dump their harvests on the Mexican market, devastating the small producers.

"In a country like Mexico, the government's assumption that the market will sort everything out is irresponsible and absurd," Suárez says. "It leads to a policy void and a very uncertain situation in which food security is in danger."

Suárez argues that the only answer is for the government to inject large amounts of cash and effort into modernising the rural economy with the smallholder at the centre of the plan. That and renegotiating the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement (Nafta) to keep tariffs protecting local produce intact. The tariffs affecting corn, beans and sugar are due to be lifted in January 2008.

A campaign called Sin Maíz No Hay País (No Corn, No Country), trying to bring together all the fears and complaints, was launched in August 2007. Meanwhile, Mexico's politicians look as though they are feeling the pressure to jump on the biofuel bandwagon and join the US and Brazil, the world's leader in producing sugar cane-based ethanol. Nagged by the knowledge that the country's oil reserves are dwindling, Mexico's parliament passed a law several months ago to encourage a home biofuel industry to start. But the bill is expected to be amended with a ban on using corn as a fuel source.

This should please Doña Catalina, furiously flipping her tortillas every day just a few miles from where the earliest evidence of domestication of corn in the world was found. "Poor corn," she says. "It isn't meant to go in cars. It is meant to feed our children and our grandchildren. And their grandchildren, too."

Copyright Guardian News & Media Ltd 2007

Homepage photo by Prometeo Rodríguez Lucero

Now more than ever…

chinadialogue is at the heart of the battle for truth on climate change and its challenges at this critical time.

Our readers are valued by us and now, for the first time, we are asking for your support to help maintain the rigorous, honest reporting and analysis on climate change that you value in a 'post-truth' era.

Support chinadialogue

发表评论 Post a comment

评论通过管理员审核后翻译成中文或英文。 最大字符 1200。

Comments are translated into either Chinese or English after being moderated. Maximum characters 1200.

评论 comments

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

应该来中国看看

中国粮食的涨价比你们疯狂多了

Come and see what's happening in China

The price of crops in China is soaring much more wildly than Mexico.

Default avatar
匿名 | Anonymous

很难感到惊喜

为了改善环境,用玉米,大麦和其他“天然”产物来替代石油做燃料,这种想法由来已久。使玉米经过处理变成燃料这一想法确实比燃烧石油好多了,但这样的去应付大众,简简单单的就把问题的本质-过度的消费转化到能源上来,这可并非长久之计。我们该做的,就是要消除每个人都要有车,都要有数字电视机的想法,以及在人迹罕至之地依然无所谓的安装路灯的现象—平均20盏路灯每人。总有一天我们会把这世界弄得肮脏不堪,那时,将无药可救,大家只能游走在废弃的机器旁,我们的后代将会非常痛苦,他们也会去拷问我们为什么就不采取点措施改变我们的生活方式呢?这太难了,没法做到。

Hardly surprising

This was always going to happen - by 'going green' in changing the source of fuel from petroleum to corn, barley and other 'natural' products. This is not a long term solution for we're simply shifting the symptom of the real problem - mass consumption - to a different resource that appeases the general public because the idea that you're processing corn for fuel sounds a hell of a lot less evil than oil!
What we need to cut out is the notion that everyone needs a car, that everyone needs a plasma television, that it's alright to leave streetlights on in areas so sparsely populated that there are 20 lights per human being in the locale.
One day we're going to get to a stage where the world is a filthy, dirty place, where nothing works and everyone walks around with dead machines sitting all over the place. Our future generations will have a hard time wondering why the hell we didn't take more drastic measures to change our lifestyles. 'It's too hard' doesn't cut it.